Battledome Suggestions Topic - Page 3


 Topic: Battledome Suggestions Topic
Users reading this topic: There are no members reading this topic.
Poll: Which name would you prefer for a new subsection?
28 vote(s) since September 25, 2013 20:58
Battle Colosseum (16) (57%)
Battles of Rome (1) (4%)
Battledome Debates (3) (11%)
Battledome Stadium (4) (14%)
Gladiator's Arena (4) (14%)
  Posted on November 28, 2012 07:04
hyuugaitachi007
Rank: member

Forum Rank:
Akatsuki

Posts: 8205
Joined on:
August 30, 2007
#31
It's very nice to hear several of your ideas. As Uber said, we have been discussing your suggestions and have already been set on doing something about the problems that plague the section soon.

In addition, Minato-Sempai's idea is a brilliant one indeed. I'd like to discuss that with the staff as well. Perhaps, however, instead of having a dedicated section for that, we can have official, staff-held Battledome tournaments that will be closely monitored. Just an idea that sprung up from Sempai's original thought, which have come up here before too.

Although, I really do like his idea. What do you guys think?

EDIT: Also, we are going to turn off the post count in this section to refrain the amount of "useless" or redundant topics. Perhaps, if we follow Sempai's ideas, we would only allow post count in that new section.
  Posted on February 10, 2013 21:41
zabuza-mist
Rank: member

Forum Rank:
Sannin

Posts: 3609
Joined on:
November 25, 2009
#32
make sure it isnt limited to just anime make sure u can do cartoons real life +
| Thread | Recruitment | Chat | Gift From Ada <3 | Nice | Bio |

| Best In The World | IncarnateZab | Selena Abused This Space | Knees 2 Faces |
  Posted on April 25, 2013 17:07
Omerotsu
Rank: member

Forum Rank:
Jounin

Posts: 2764
Joined on:
October 19, 2008
#33
Battledome was more fun when people could argue more lol. Now only few explain there points really well, while others just give a name and a few words. Idk Battledome used to be hipe for me, but nobodies really challenging me anymore because all of the other smart people are always saying the same things that I say or that I would say.
  Posted on April 25, 2013 23:16
dbzfannie
Rank: moderator

Forum Rank:
ANBU

Posts: 3060
Joined on:
December 27, 2008
#34
As everyone said, most battles are using the same characters.
How about a list with some populair Anime's? It might come in handy.

Also, an extra subforum for tournaments might be possible.
You can have them in category's like: Favorite male, Favorite Female, hottest character and more,
Each member can post 1 of their favorite characters to join a tournament hosted by a moderator.
  Posted on April 26, 2013 04:29
Omerotsu
Rank: member

Forum Rank:
Jounin

Posts: 2764
Joined on:
October 19, 2008
#35
hyuugaitachi007 wrote:
It's very nice to hear several of your ideas. As Uber said, we have been discussing your suggestions and have already been set on doing something about the problems that plague the section soon.

In addition, Minato-Sempai's idea is a brilliant one indeed. I'd like to discuss that with the staff as well. Perhaps, however, instead of having a dedicated section for that, we can have official, staff-held Battledome tournaments that will be closely monitored. Just an idea that sprung up from Sempai's original thought, which have come up here before too.

Although, I really do like his idea. What do you guys think?


EDIT: Also, we are going to turn off the post count in this section to refrain the amount of "useless" or redundant topics. Perhaps, if we follow Sempai's ideas, we would only allow post count in that new section.

I like the idea. Although if we are going to do this kind of idea, we're gonna have only include characters that have enough feats. Like right now, Izuna and Tobirama don't even really have much feats, but everyone still puts them in matches. You know what I mean? Just giving an example.

Also rather than go by what the character " would do", I think we should just go by what the character "could do" and if what they could do beats what the other character could do. Allot of people say, "oh he wouldn't do that", but it's like, if you put Kakashi against Sakura, would Kakashi raikiri her? In the anime of course he wouldn't, but in the battledome, the basic objective for each character should just be to kill the other character in the best way possible that someone is able to explain. Basically an "All Out" sort of idea. Keeps it simplier so that we don't have to argue about what a character would do, when we should be debating about what they could do to win.

Another thing. People seem to think high level Ninjas CANNOT lose to lower level ones. This is either do to reputation, or due to displays of great power. Here's an example. Tsunade vs Tayuya. Let's just say Tsunade can't summon. Tayuya can catch people in a genjutsu by using sound. So it'd be easy to catch most right? The use of her Demon Flute was even able to catch Itachi and Sasuke. So it should be able to catch Tsunade since Tsunade hasn't shown to be Genjutsu proof. Shouldn't she be able to catch Tsunade in the Genjutsu and I don't know, maybe slit her throat or decapitate her, or stab her in the heart for a quick death. But people would never accept that, because of her rep and displayed power. Just an example, not saying Tayuya would win or anything. But you see, the thing about Naruto, that people don't get, is that Kishi has given certain characters certain powers that realistically would dominate characters that have appeared to be stronger due to the plot.

Here's a personal example, that might be easier to understand, since nobody really knows who these made up people are, it will be less biased (if I spelled that correctly =/ never spelled it before lol):
"Kakamoto, the strongest swordsmen in history, lead his nations to victory blah blah. Okay? But that other person, Shikipoopoo, the one you made look like a bitch, he can blow up things and toss bombs and stuff, So how can Kakamoto block the bombs when all he has is swords?"

"Naw bro, Kakamoto is a legend, he could never lose to some low bomb specialist from the slums that nobody even knows"

"Okay so how can he block the bombs?"

"Idk, he's Kakamoto dude".

Just some shit I made up, but do you get what I trying to point out? It's Kishi's plot that makes things look the way they do. Like for example, why didn't Edo Deidara just self destruct as many times as he wanted? Plot... So it's like, do we have to go by what Kishi would go by even though it doesn't add up, or do we go by what makes more sense, because Kishi didn't really think about the powers he was giving people, and gave some lower rank ninjas skills that are actually better than some higher ranking ninjas.

Idk if I'm explaining good, but's it's just a problem that I see, that makes debating more difficult due to lack of acceptance of another characters power. It may be a complex thought, so I'm sorry.
  Posted on April 26, 2013 04:51
hyuugaitachi007
Rank: member

Forum Rank:
Akatsuki

Posts: 8205
Joined on:
August 30, 2007
#36
I definitely see your points; they're valid, alright. I'm loving the input, and soon, there will be something new that will happen to the whole section. Keep an eye out.

I'm excited, and I think the we, the staff, could come up with a draft of a possible tournament with guidelines you have all suggested.

Do remember though that the Battledome is for anime/series fights. They're not for favorites, etc. Those belong in Otaku Chat.
  Posted on April 28, 2013 05:06
choppy
Rank: member

Forum Rank:
Jounin

Posts: 2664
Joined on:
January 2, 2009
#37
So if you're still after ideas I had one for a tournament but have nowhere near the time to maintain it, so anyone who likes the idea can run with it or do what they want with it.

Gather entrants and set up a tournament style bracket. Gather either some mods or some respectable battledome participants to be judges (maybe 3 would be a good number, so there's never a tie). Each week list a number of battles from the naruto-verse and the participants have one week to explain (in one post only), who they think would win in one of the battles.

Now there's a bunch of strategy involved in timing and choosing which battle you want to debate. Do you see who you're matched up against and wait for him to post first, so that you can rebut if you think he's wrong and hence get the upper hand. You could wait and, if you think your opponent is right, choose a different fight, or argue for the same person he did, but in a better manner. Or do you hurry and post first because you see a matchup that you know you have a sound knowledge of. etc etc.

The judges would choose a winner for each matchup between members based on who posts the most convincing argument via references to manga, clearly defined arguments, presentation etc.

Not a lot of work for the judges, they'll be reading a few battledome arguments once per week. And the participants stay motivated due to the knockout style competition.

Anyway, just a thought :)

Sig by Vale the god
  Posted on May 27, 2013 14:53
frozen26
Rank: member

Forum Rank:
Jounin

Posts: 1648
Joined on:
October 12, 2011
#38
I think the mods should start locking topics or delete repetitive topics and delete one -sided bouts if the person who post the topic doesn't explain why Hulk vs Mr. Satan would make for a good match.
  Posted on May 29, 2013 17:56
frozen26
Rank: member

Forum Rank:
Jounin

Posts: 1648
Joined on:
October 12, 2011
#39
Or topics have to be approved by mods before being posted. This would prevent random nonsense topics or duplicate topics.

Also, each topic should have a poll and after a week or so, the mods lock the topic declaring the winner being who ever got the highest poll. Also, edit the title to reflect the winner so for example if the topic is Goku vs. Superman. After the polling is complete the mod would change the topic title to (W)Goku vs Superman. Link to other similar topics would be cool especially if the scenario is different and maybe reflect what number battle it is for that topic. Like if there has been 14 different Goku vs Superman battles, when the mod approve the title he states Goku vs Superman: Battle 14. A summary of there stats could be added. If Goku beat superman 12 times then his ranking against Superman would be 12 to 2 and Superman's would be 2 to 12, Also, you add just a general win lose streak for all the battle topics that include Goku. So if has had 100 battle in battle dome and only lost 5 times his record would be 95-5. Could be some draws too I guess if the polls are equal. May need a battledome mod to manage. My vote is for Ramkec. He started from the bottom now he's a legend.
  Posted on June 29, 2013 22:21
markua
Rank: member

Forum Rank:
Jounin

Posts: 1612
Joined on:
December 12, 2007
#40
I have a fair battle-dome suggestion. An offficial list of tried/tested battles [disregarding fanboyism] and who the clear victor would be in the presented scenerio/situation. This would help reduce spam at least. Links to those old topics can be placed on the thread for reference purposes. Or reason(s) for why the victory was granted.

This would enable someone with a different opinion to post a rematch in order to say why the stated is false. Or some shit like that.
  Posted on July 12, 2013 03:12
lilnaruto_legend
Rank: member

Forum Rank:
Jounin

Posts: 2980
Joined on:
November 17, 2010
#41
markua wrote:
I have a fair battle-dome suggestion. An offficial list of tried/tested battles [disregarding fanboyism] and who the clear victor would be in the presented scenerio/situation. This would help reduce spam at least. Links to those old topics can be placed on the thread for reference purposes. Or reason(s) for why the victory was granted.

This would enable someone with a different opinion to post a rematch in order to say why the stated is false. Or some shit like that.
I honestly don't feel like the battldome has a spamming problem. Also what you said about a guide sort of seems like instead of it being the battledome it would just be a fight guide.

Message me if you want to know the secrets of the universe. Mods signing sigs is a real thing? Just assumed people put the stuff there themselves.
  Posted on July 12, 2013 05:39
EarsOfGod
Rank: member

Forum Rank:
Special Jounin

Posts: 730
Joined on:
May 31, 2010
#42
Guys, please keep suggestions coming.

We are seriously taking your ideas into consideration!

You's a lil nigga.. I'm beyond that.
  Posted on July 13, 2013 18:19
markua
Rank: member

Forum Rank:
Jounin

Posts: 1612
Joined on:
December 12, 2007
#43
lilnaruto_legend wrote:
markua wrote:
I have a fair battle-dome suggestion. An offficial list of tried/tested battles [disregarding fanboyism] and who the clear victor would be in the presented scenerio/situation. This would help reduce spam at least. Links to those old topics can be placed on the thread for reference purposes. Or reason(s) for why the victory was granted.

This would enable someone with a different opinion to post a rematch in order to say why the stated is false. Or some shit like that.
I honestly don't feel like the battldome has a spamming problem. Also what you said about a guide sort of seems like instead of it being the battledome it would just be a fight guide.

Yeah? I see countless topics where the thread starter asks for a character x vs y. But the majority just goes with a random other character. This happens a lot. And by spamming, I mean like topics have a tendency to pop up every so often. Like...there was a phase of itachi vs this and that and so on.

A guide for fights as you call it would in itself serve to dispute popular myths. One such is how Itachi would win against Nagato (not debating for a fact). Honestly the other way is also most likely possible.

What I was suggesting is not meant to reduce the number of topics posted, but increase the number in diversity which increases in complexity as time goes on. And therefore; Battledome would actually be a whole lot more interesting to post on than it currently is.
  Posted on July 14, 2013 06:35
lilnaruto_legend
Rank: member

Forum Rank:
Jounin

Posts: 2980
Joined on:
November 17, 2010
#44
markua wrote:
lilnaruto_legend wrote:
markua wrote:
I have a fair battle-dome suggestion. An offficial list of tried/tested battles [disregarding fanboyism] and who the clear victor would be in the presented scenerio/situation. This would help reduce spam at least. Links to those old topics can be placed on the thread for reference purposes. Or reason(s) for why the victory was granted.

This would enable someone with a different opinion to post a rematch in order to say why the stated is false. Or some shit like that.
I honestly don't feel like the battldome has a spamming problem. Also what you said about a guide sort of seems like instead of it being the battledome it would just be a fight guide.

Yeah? I see countless topics where the thread starter asks for a character x vs y. But the majority just goes with a random other character. This happens a lot. And by spamming, I mean like topics have a tendency to pop up every so often. Like...there was a phase of itachi vs this and that and so on.

A guide for fights as you call it would in itself serve to dispute popular myths. One such is how Itachi would win against Nagato (not debating for a fact). Honestly the other way is also most likely possible.

What I was suggesting is not meant to reduce the number of topics posted, but increase the number in diversity which increases in complexity as time goes on. And therefore; Battledome would actually be a whole lot more interesting to post on than it currently is.
The fact is, most people on this site know mostly naruto with a few other animes on the side. Also, almost all of the possible fights have already been posted so kinda pointless?

We have a common misconceptions topic but it's really outdated. Making a topic that says 'this character will win" is stupid as it would stop any discussion from actually happening.

Message me if you want to know the secrets of the universe. Mods signing sigs is a real thing? Just assumed people put the stuff there themselves.
  Posted on July 14, 2013 07:22
markua
Rank: member

Forum Rank:
Jounin

Posts: 1612
Joined on:
December 12, 2007
#45
lilnaruto_legend wrote:
markua wrote:
lilnaruto_legend wrote:
I honestly don't feel like the battldome has a spamming problem. Also what you said about a guide sort of seems like instead of it being the battledome it would just be a fight guide.

Yeah? I see countless topics where the thread starter asks for a character x vs y. But the majority just goes with a random other character. This happens a lot. And by spamming, I mean like topics have a tendency to pop up every so often. Like...there was a phase of itachi vs this and that and so on.

A guide for fights as you call it would in itself serve to dispute popular myths. One such is how Itachi would win against Nagato (not debating for a fact). Honestly the other way is also most likely possible.

What I was suggesting is not meant to reduce the number of topics posted, but increase the number in diversity which increases in complexity as time goes on. And therefore; Battledome would actually be a whole lot more interesting to post on than it currently is.
The fact is, most people on this site know mostly naruto with a few other animes on the side. Also, almost all of the possible fights have already been posted so kinda pointless?

We have a common misconceptions topic but it's really outdated. Making a topic that says 'this character will win" is stupid as it would stop any discussion from actually happening.

A thread like what exists stops the debating process based on acceptable facts and common misunderstandings. For example, what my proposed thread does is get a couple of characters to vs and with reason state why/how/when the winner would win; in addition to a certain condition given. Debate is always open to decide otherwise, and must be taken into consideration if facts are undeniable.

Note, I am not simply proposing a list with people and victors. I'm proposing a thread that would declare the victor based on what moves he would use and under what conditions/restrictions. Based on that, it would be possible to add an additional instance where the victor of a previous condition end up defeated in another. One good example would be Edo Tensei Itachi who makes up for his weaknesses alive.
Dee-Jay, Orihime_Chan_01.
Admins online: 0 - Global moderators online: 0 - Moderators online: 0 - Members online: 2